Back to Blog

Argue Better

relationships

Not arguing isn't always a sign of a strong relationship.

Sometimes it means you are biting your tongue, pretending, or agreeing because telling the truth feels uncomfortable.

A friend and I had an argument we handled poorly. When we returned to the conversation, we learned something important: avoiding every disagreement wasn't going to help us grow closer.

We are both avoidant. Leaving the conversation can feel easier than staying in it. But getting back to where we were before the argument wasn't necessarily the goal.

We wanted to understand each other better and take the relationship deeper.

Let disagreement make room for honesty

When you disagree, you have an opportunity to communicate and be your authentic self.

If your rule is never to argue, you may have to hide what you think. That creates distance and resentment instead of real connection.

It takes courage to bring up something the other person may not agree with. It also takes courage to share an insecurity or thought that doesn't seem logical.

You don't have to pretend everything in your brain is pretty before you let someone know you.

But the key is to own it.

Share your feelings without assigning them the job of fixing you

There is a difference between explaining what you are experiencing and demanding that someone solve it.

The mistake is telling someone how you feel and immediately asking what they will do to fix it. You make your feelings their assignment.

Instead, acknowledge that your thoughts are creating the feeling. Tell them what is happening in your mind and that you want them to understand it.

You might explain that you are having thoughts you know may be unreasonable, that you don't blame them, and that you aren't asking them to fix you.

That is vulnerability. It gives them room to explain their perspective or reassure you without making them responsible for your emotional life.

It also makes room for them to share honestly.

Expect misunderstandings

Communication moves through several layers.

You have a thought. You translate it into words, which may not fully express what you meant. The other person hears those words and interprets them through their thoughts. Then they respond.

There are many opportunities for misunderstanding, blame, and defensiveness in that process.

Knowing that helps you leave space for the conversation. It may take longer than you want for both people to feel understood.

If your only goal is being right, getting an apology, or shutting the other person down, you can miss that opportunity.

I told my friend that the difficult conversation wasn't meaningless drama. It was part of the good stuff: learning that we could disagree and still come back to each other.

Your worthiness is not being negotiated

An argument can feel like an attack on who you are.

You may go into fight or flight, believing you need to win or get away before you are hurt.

Notice that response. You can hear something you don't like, allow the other person to have their thoughts, and stay present.

You can be upset about a topic while your love for someone remains constant. Their worthiness remains complete, and so does yours.

When I coach parents of teenagers, I remind them that conflict can be a place where their kids learn how to get upset and reconcile. They can learn that disagreement doesn't automatically mean connection and love disappear.

Adults need that experience, too.

Decide what kind of relationship you want

A girlfriend told me about a trip where one friend said hurtful things. Everyone noticed, but nobody addressed it.

One person withdrew afterward. Another continued the friendship without talking about what happened.

I wondered what might have become possible if they had asked about the comments and explained how they were interpreting them.

There may have been something going on they could understand. The conversation could have opened a door to more honesty.

I also know the fear of losing a relationship through confrontation isn't unfounded. Some people will not have the conversation.

And not every relationship needs to become deeper. You may be comfortable with an acquaintance-level connection and choose to let something go.

But if you want a close, enduring relationship, notice whether keeping the peace is requiring a version of you that pretends.

That can keep the real you out of the relationship.

Make a plan before the next argument

Talk when you aren't already in conflict.

Ask how you want to handle a disagreement or a moment when one of you is upset.

My friend and I agreed we would come to the table. We wouldn't simply ghost, block, or run away. We would have the hard conversation until we felt we had heard each other and been heard.

That doesn't require ending every conversation in agreement. You can understand each person's truth and still disagree.

Allow some initial resistance and defensiveness. Then keep creating space for the actual conversation.

Ask what kind of person you want to be when there is tension. It only takes one person to stay calm and hold space for the other to come back.

Don't underestimate an apology

I have reacted defensively and said things I didn't want to say. I appreciate being able to come back, own it, and resolve it instead of living with the emotional hangover.

An apology can be simple. You can be sorry for what you said, how you reacted, or that a misunderstanding happened, even when your intention was different from what they heard.

Letting go of needing to be right can bring you closer.

I have coached people who are at an impasse with a sister they love. Asking whether they could apologize and say they love her can soften the whole conversation.

You can start from love instead of resistance.

Learn to argue as a skill instead of treating it only as something to avoid. Tell the truth, own your thoughts, listen, and make room for repair.

Being right is overrated. Loving is so much better.

Don't miss a beat!

New moves, motivation, and classes delivered to your inbox. 

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.

Based on The Life Coach School Podcast, originally hosted by Brooke Castillo, now Brooke Hicks.